Web Only / Features » October 9, 2012
Paul Ryan Hefts White Man’s Burden
The real news isn’t Paul Ryan cutting off an interview; it’s the racist comment he made just before.
Ryan volunteered the phrase "inner cities" out of nowhere, except his own preconceptions about the link between violent crime and inner cities—i.e. where poor blacks and Latinos live.
Internet pundits made hay today over a clip released by BuzzFeed that shows a “testy” Republican vice presidential candidate Paul Ryan aborting an interview segment with Michigan’s ABC12 News. The Ryan campaign sought to short-circuit the criticism by saying Ryan made an appropriate response to a “weird question” by the local ABC reporter.
But what Paul Ryan said before that termination makes weird look like a virtue. Ryan’s comments about solving inner-city problems were unabashedly racist.
Asked if “this country has a gun problem,” Ryan immediately retorted: “This country has a crime problem.”
The answer is a textbook “pivot”– a technique candidates use to slip by the actual question in order to choose a controlled response that is on message.
But in expanding on his pivot, Ryan jumped mouth first into a briar patch of racist stereotypes. After saying the United States has “good, strong gun laws” that just need better enforcement, Ryan defined the source of violent crime problem and offered his solution:
But the best thing to help prevent violent crime in the inner cities is to bring opportunity in the inner cities, is to help people get out of poverty in the inner cities, is to help teach people good discipline, good character. That is civil society. That's what charities, and civic groups, and churches do to help one another make sure that they can realize the value in one another.
Nobody calls Park Avenue, Hyde Park or Rodeo Drive the “inner city.” And even though Sarah Jessica Parker and Donald Trump live in urban centers, no one refers to her West Village brownstone or his gilded penthouse as inner-city digs.
“Inner city” is code for impoverished black and Latino urban neighborhoods; inner city is a euphemism for ghetto.
Nor did anyone ask Ryan about inner cities in the interview segment posted on BuzzFeed. Ryan volunteered the phrase out of nowhere, except his own preconceptions about the link between violent crime and inner cities—i.e. where poor blacks and Latinos live. He proposed alleviating their poverty and preventing crime by helping teach inner-city people good discipline and character. For, according to Ryan, that is what constitutes “civil society.” As for the roles of education, health care, jobs, veterans’ benefits, child care and decent food? Shucks, the “best thing” is to just leave it to charities, civic groups and churches to teach those inner city people to control their urges.
Until then, hide the white womenfolk and the good silver from the inner-city denizens, who lack the “discipline” to resist violent crimes or the “good character” to get out of poverty.
Oh, I’m sorry. Were we talking about the gun problem?
Help In These Times Continue Publishing
Progressive journalism is needed now more than ever, and In These Times needs you.
Like many nonprofits, we expect In These Times to struggle financially as a result of this crisis. But in a moment like this, we can’t afford to scale back or be silent, not when so much is at stake. If it is within your means, please consider making an emergency donation to help fund our coverage during this critical time.
Terry J. Allen
Terry J. Allen is a veteran investigative reporter/editor who has covered local and international politics and health and science issues. Her work has appeared in the Guardian, Boston Globe, Times Argus, Harper’s, the Nation.com, Salon.com, and New Scientist . She has been an editor at Amnesty International, In These Times , and Corpwatch.com. She is also a photographer. Her portraits of people sitting in some of the 1900 cars lined up outside a Newport, Vt., food drop can be seen on www.flickr.com/photos/terryallen/albums. Terry can be contacted at email@example.com or through www.terryjallen.com.