Email this article to a friend

The ITT List

Thursday, Jul 12, 2007, 6:19 pm

Judge Reggie Directs Snark at Bush’s False Characterization of Libby Sentence as “Excess

By Brian Zick

Email this article to a friend

Jane Hamsher at firedoglake quotes from the footnotes in Judge Walton's memorandum opinion, in which he - with admitted reluctance - concludes that Bush's commutation of Scooter Libby's prison sentence does not "offend the Constitution," and so orders Libby to comply with the terms of supervised release:
In commuting the defendant’s thirty-month term of incarceration, the President stated that the sentence imposed by this Court was “excessive” and that two years of supervised release and a $250,000 alone are a “harsh punishment” for an individual convicted on multiple counts of perjury, obstruction of justice, and making false statements to federal investigators... Although it is certainly the President’s prerogative to justify the exercise of his constitutional commutation power in whatever manner he chooses (or even to decline to provide a reason for his actions altogether), the Court notes that the term of incarceration imposed in this case was determined after a careful consideration of each of the requisite statutory factors,... and was consistent with the bottom end of the applicable sentencing range as properly calculated under the United States Sentencing Guidelines.
(...)
Indeed, only recently the President’s Attorney General called for the passage of legislation to “restore the binding nature of the sentencing guidelines so that the bottom of the recommended sentencing range would be a minimum for judges, not merely a suggestion,”... a stance that is fully consonant with the policies of this Administration as a whole. In light of these considerations, and given the indisputable importance of “provid[ing] certainty and fairness in sentencing . . . [and] avoid[ing] unwarranted sentencing disparities,”... it is fair to say that the Court is somewhat perplexed as to how its sentence could accurately be characterized as “excessive.”
View Comments