Tuesday, Jan 4, 2011, 6:49 am
New California Governor Jerry Brown: Unions’ Friend or Foe?
California public employees unions enjoyed a moment of victory Monday as Jerry Brown took office as governor, a position he last held almost three decades ago. In contrast to outgoing Republican Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, who made national headlines for brutal battles with union nurses, teachers and firefighters, unions campaigned heavily for Brown.
It was an absolute no-contest as far as unions were concerned; Brown’s opponent was former Silicon Valley CEO Meg Whitman, who showed her feelings toward low-wage workers by calling immigration officials on her undocumented housekeeper. The California Federation of Labor intensified its get-out-the-vote campaign for the gubernatorial election; Whitman’s spokesman decried public union spending, about $25 million on the election. Union members said they were just trying to counter the $104 million Whitman spent on her own campaign.
The big question now is: How will Brown deal with public employees unions in the face of a crushing budget deficit which Republicans and others have blamed largely on supposed cushy contracts enjoyed by these employees.
TV news channel KUSI described a campaign trail event where Brown and his wife tried to walk a fine line, shaking hands with union members at a hot dog cookout but ignoring the podium and microphone they had ready for him, eliciting boo's from attendees.
In the days since the election Brown has warned of impending cuts, including to public programs and agencies. In response, teachers unions -- which critics say are in bed with Brown -- have called for raising property taxes or other measures. Brown meanwhile has talked of creating half a million “green” jobs, (presumably predominantly private sector but unionized or well-paid), an idea met with significant skepticism.
He will probably ask voters in a special election to raise taxes. The real question is what will he do about the public employee unions, their growing labor contracts and their swelling pension demands? There are very few who believe Jerry Brown can and will stand up to the unions and if he does not, there is not much chance to solve the states' "outyear" budget problems.
Conservative blogger Dwight L. Schwab Jr. lambasted Brown for kowtowing to SEIU for political points, negotiating what he calls exorbitant public employees salaries which the cash-strapped state can hardly afford.
While California public employees have doubtless received significantly more generous pay and pensions over the years than most private employees and other states’ public employees in similar positions, union members balk at the idea that they are single-handedly to blame for a budget deficit that has also been impacted by everything from the Enron debacle to generous corporate welfare to the economic crisis caused largely by Wall Street and subprime lending malfeasance.
Not to mention the economic stimulation that theoretically would have been caused by the public employees’ spending their relatively high salaries over the years—helping to offset other budget woes. One union member commented on KUSI’s story:
It's not like the State workers have asked for pay raises across the board. The majority of us haven't had a pay raise in years and the 15% cut I and the other 200,000 workers took last year didn't even pay the interest on the deficit the State has. The majority of us know the deficit, in fact we know the problems intimately well but aren't being listened to.
A similar debate had raged in the blogosphere, editorial pages and public forums during Brown’s years as governor of Oakland. Among other things, Brown was accused of currying favor with public employees by generously padding their overtime budgets. The LA Times reported:
In all, 82 full-time employees doubled their annual salaries with overtime at least once during Brown's time as mayor, city payroll records show. Twenty-one employees took home more than $100,000 in overtime in a single year; 333 earned more than $50,000 in overtime in single year. Of the roughly 4,000 city employees making at least $20,000 in base pay, 681 increased their annual salaries by 50% or more with overtime in at least one year of Brown's tenure.
One online commenter said in March:
Sooner or later we will have to face the financial mess that the public employee unions have wrought on California. And we have Moonbeam to thank for making this mess.
Any of you who are not working 6-day weeks and 12- hour days owe a big debt to the union movement. But you would have to understand history to know that.
Meanwhile other labor activists said Brown was hardly a real friend of workers, describing his support of Oakland police attacking longshore workers and privatization of education and other services.
Teacher and Oakland Education Association union leader Jack Gerson said in a video posted last spring:
"Jerry Brown was a huge advocate of charter schools, and started two directly himself,” referring to an arts school and a military institute. Gerson said that during Brown’s tenure in Oakland, the number of charter schools roughly doubled and the number of charter school students quadrupled from about 2,000 to 8,000. “Jerry Brown is the biggest ally to privatization of education in the U.S."
ILWU Local 10 longshore union executive board member Jack Heyman noted that Brown supported the union in 1998, “but it was a totally opportunistic move on Brown’s part…he was trying to build a base of support running for mayor of Oakland.”
“Who showed up but Jerry Brown, because the cameras were rolling and the radio stations were there. So he got publicity for himself under the guise of supporting labor. But Jerry Brown is for Jerry Brown, and he always has been.”
Heyman noted that Brown "gave the green light' for Oakland police to brutally attack longshoremen and other picketers at an anti-war protest on the docks in 2003.
“It’s hypocritical – not only does he claim to stand for labor, but for civil liberties and people’s right to free speech,” Heyman said. "It's hypocritical on his part because not only does he claim to stand for labor, but he claims to stand for civil liberties, for people's right to free speech...but here he was giving the green light for police to attack not only anti-war protesters but longshoremen in the port."
Never has independent journalism mattered more. Help hold power to account: Subscribe to In These Times magazine, or make a tax-deductible donation to fund this reporting.
Kari Lydersen, an In These Times contributing editor, is a Chicago-based journalist and instructor who currently works at Northwestern University. Her work has appeared in the New York Times, the Washington Post, the Chicago Reader and The Progressive, among other publications. Her most recent book is Mayor 1%: Rahm Emanuel and the Rise of Chicago's 99 Percent. She is also the co-author of Shoot an Iraqi: Art, Life and Resistance Under the Gun and the author of Revolt on Goose Island: The Chicago Factory Takeover, and What it Says About the Economic Crisis. Look for an updated reissue of Revolt on Goose Island in 2014. In 2011, she was awarded a Studs Terkel Community Media Award for her work. She can be reached at [email protected]
More by Kari Lydersen
- Chicago Window Workers Who Occupied Their Factory in 2008 Win New Bankruptcy Payout
- Chicago Car Wash Workers: Owner Took Their Tips, Said They Were His
- New Play Chronicles the Toll of the Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill on Workers
- Railroad Work Is Getting More and More Dangerous. These Workers Want To Change That.
- “It Is Right to Resist”: The Revolutionary Art of Pilsen’s Jose Guerrero