Me, You, Them
Directed by Andrucha Waddington
A Time for Drunken Horses
Directed by Bahman Ghobadi
George Washington
Directed by David Gordon Green
The Toronto International Film Festival, which celebrated its 25th
anniversary in September, is now an event that ranks with Cannes,
Venice and Berlin. Loaded with starpower (Pacino, Gere, Paltrow),
and glossed with glitz, it's also an astonishing demonstration of
the range of filmmaking worldwide.
There's the shamelessly spectacular, like Taiwanese Ang Lee's romantic
costumer set
 |
Ménage à Me,
You Them.
|
in imperial China and starring heartthrob Chow Yun-Fat, Crouching
Tiger, Hidden Dragon. There's in-your-face weirdness, like 101
Reykjavik, an Icelandic tale of a teen-ager who gets his mother's
lesbian lover pregnant; the film features long, clinically accurate
scenes of party sex. There's Hong Kong aesthete Wong Kar-Wai's rapturous
meditation on longing, In the Mood for Love, an ecstasy of
complementary colors and oblique angles. Oh, and how about the tough-girl-in-love
boxing story Girlfight, by American director Karyn Kusama?
After more than 300 films debut in little more than a week, 300-some
sets of filmmakers take a bow, and hundreds of agents rack up monstrous
cellphone bills, and hundreds of critics stagger out into the light,
all realize they each have attended a different festival than the
others.
Some of this global cinematic cornucopia spills out into American
cineplexes, defying the truism that Americans don't watch foreign
films and never read subtitles. That's partly because conglomerates
have snapped up and launched their own art-house distributors (Miramax,
Sony Classics, Screen Gems, Universal Focus, New Line and so on),
which are stocking the unprecedented number of movie screens. The
global nature of the cinematic marketplace makes even a money-losing
theatrical launch part of a long-term, global marketing plan that
can pay off down the line.
These new facts of life in the film business have made it possible
to market a new hybrid product: the little international charmer
of a movie, heralding from somewhere that doesn't make the front
page of the Times, perhaps somewhere exotically post-colonial,
and celebrating the struggle of good people to endure. These movies
can be lush and sexy (Like Water for Chocolate, from Mexico),
mournfully dramatic (The Color of Paradise, from Iran), knowingly
funny (East Is East, an English film about the South Asian
diasporic community in Britain), a downright hoot (The Full Monty,
about English steelworkers displaced by globalization) or handsome
as handsome can be (like a whole run of Chinese films from the so-called
Fifth Generation directors). They take the traditions established
by neorealist directors in the '40s and '50s--who in films as diverse
as The Bicycle Thief and Pather Panchali awakened
viewers' demands for common human decency--and create a new movie
formula.
Me, You, Them, by Brazilian director Andrucha Waddington,
is a nicely burnished example of the new, farm-bred international
charmer. Set in Brazil's impoverished northeast, it builds on tradition.
In the '60s, Brazilian "new cinema" was an angry example of Third
World neorealism. Directors such as Nelson Pereira dos Santos (Barren
Lives) and Glauber Rocha (Black God, White Devil) rocked
international audiences and horrified Brazil's military government
with films that featured a northeastern peasantry that was suddenly
stirring politically. After a miserable decline hastened by censorship,
persecution of artists and a failure to protect local markets, in
the '90s Brazilian cinema was revived as a commercial enterprise.
Two years ago, the Brazilian feature Central Station, about
an embittered old woman and an orphan who search the northeast for
a way to go home, became an international award winner and box office
pleasure.
Me, You, Them is based on a true story of bigamy among the
peasantry. We meet Darlene (Regina Casé) who, pregnant in
a makeshift wedding gown, is stood up at the church door; she takes
the next bus out of town. Three years later, she returns just in
time for her mother's funeral. She accepts an offer to wed from
surly storekeeper Osias (Lima Duarte), and proceeds to make a life
out of hard work in the cane fields and at home. Her sexiness defies
the dirt, misery and cruelty of her condition; her next baby looks
nothing like her husband, creating suspicion and deepening her husband's
brutality.
Her efforts to flee Osias' abuse fail, and she returns, having
given her oldest son to his father--her foreman in the cane fields--so
that he can be educated. When her shy, single brother-in-law (Stenio
Garcia) comes to stay, she finds sympathy and some help in the kitchen;
soon he gets a son. Their peculiar arrangement works until a handsome
new worker (the very hunky Luiz Carlos Vasconcelos) shows up in
the cane fields. Then everyone has to consider the terms under which
they will accept a little happiness in a life that is otherwise
ruled by utter deprivation.
The true story from which the movie is derived was a tabloid treasure,
since it so titillatingly teased the terms of the region's patriarchal
culture. It played not only with the ruling ideology that women
are the property and subjects of men, but its companion ideology
that women also exercise a mystical power over men, through their
sexuality and their control of childbearing and domestic life. The
film also plays, more discreetly, with these assumptions, and Casˇ's
ability to project a sexy companionability carries the game a long
way. But the film never really strays far from the terms of patriarchal
culture, nor does it ever challenge the economic or political injustice
that reinforce it and still make it perfectly possible to get away
with wife-murder in the region.
It's simply up to the characters to make stone soup of it all,
and the director says as much. "Me, You, Them is a film about
ordinary human beings in a situation considered absurd, in a society
that does not accept polygamy," Waddington told a Brazilian newspaper.
"I would also say that it's a film about the rules of the game,
and of how life presents new rules every day. If people want to
be happy, they have to adapt themselves to the new rules, even if
they have to go through moments of real misery."
So there it is: neorealism nouvelle, a tasteful addition
to the global cinematic palate. In the backlands, just like in the
high-tech dotcom environment, flexibility is everything. Adapt to
polygamy if that's how you can hold on to your joie de vivre
while starving.
Other features at Toronto took the grand legacy of neorealism
in other directions. Consider A Time for Drunken Horses.
The film, set in Kurdistan, was made by Iranian director Bahman
Ghobadi, who grew up in the region. The Iranian government both
supports and yet suppresses a highly productive, professional cinema.
Over the years, it has become well known for films featuring children,
with stories that wend around many of the political unsayables.
Some are more cloying than others, but a few--such as Abbas Kiarostami's
Where Is the Friend's Home, Samira Makhmalbaf's The Apple
and Children of Heaven by Majid Majidi--have been splendid.
Ghobadi's film takes place in mountains dotted by Kurdish villages
(Kurds are the largest stateless group in the world) divided by
the national borders of Iran and Iraq. In a village that survives
by smuggling simple domestic goods across borders, a family is orphaned
when the father is killed by a buried landmine. The children rally
to save their ailing handicapped brother; and finally the teen-aged
eldest brother, hoping to earn money for the child's operation,
sets out on the smugglers' route, through landmine-laced terrain
so terrifying that horses must be fed whiskey even to attempt it.
The landscape is as forbidding as it is majestic, and the desperate
hope of the young people is as poignant as the adults' resignation
is terrible. Ghobadi's film takes a genre that has become all too
formulaic, and renewed its power.
George Washington--which will have a modest run in large
cities this fall--is one of those movies that astonishes you with
the strangeness of ordinary life. Made by David Gordon Green, a
24-year-old film school grad in North Carolina, it takes a group
of young teenagers in a small, down-at-heels industrial town in
the South through a Fourth of July weekend. In that time, one of
them will die, two will tempt fate, and George, the 13-year-old
African-American kid at the middle of the story, will survive. It's
shot in 35 mm in a way that makes you feel Southern heat and industrial
rot, but lets you see with young eyes the wonder of a day, a night,
a dog or a girl; it brings the term magical realism back to cinematic
life.
Green, who is white and who grew up in such a town, has won some
entirely fresh performances from young non-actors. The film is uneven;
the dialect is not always comprehensible, and the final cut clearly
left some story pieces on the floor. But when you leave George
Washington, you've watched an emerging artist who illuminates
a world; you've been reminded of the many things beyond the business
deal that festivals are for. 
|