Timothy McVeigh called it a "state-assisted suicide." That's how
he viewed his own execution by lethal injection at the federal prison
in Terre Haute, Indiana. McVeigh's execution will not numb the pain
of the 168 senseless deaths on April 19, 1995, when a massive bomb
destroyed the Alfred P. Murrah federal building in Oklahoma City.
It will not deter other acts of terrorism. Nor will it put an end
to lingering uncertainties about the massacre. There are too many
loose ends and unanswered questions for McVeigh's execution to qualify
as the end of anything.
Federal officials insist that McVeigh had only one accomplice,
Terry Nichols, who is facing life in prison for his ancillary role
in the bomb plot. The FBI says it found no evidence of a wider conspiracy,
even though the original indictment cited McVeigh, Nichols and "others
unknown." The government's case, as it stands, is flawed. For starters,
it's highly unlikely that McVeigh could have mixed the fertilizer
bomb by himself on the day before the attack, as federal prosecutors
contend. Charles Farley, a car mechanic, testified at the Nichols
trial that he saw five men gathered around a Ryder truck and other
vehicles near Geary State Lake, loading white bags of powder that
he thought was ammonium nitrate fertilizer, the same type used in
the bomb. Farley, a solid witness, had provided an exact and detailed
account of what he had seen to the FBI, but the bureau inexplicably
did not pursue this lead.
Numerous eyewitnesses placed McVeigh in the company of other people
in the days
 |
Timothy McVeigh was part
of a paranoid
far-right subculture still going strong.
JOEFF DAVIS
|
leading up to the Oklahoma City bombing. Morris John Kuper saw a person
resembling McVeigh with another man (not Nichols) walking near the
federal building shortly before the blast. When McVeigh was arrested
two days later, Kuper immediately contacted the FBI. But his report
about a possible second bomber was buried in the "misplaced" FBI files
that reappeared in May. McVeigh claimed that he alone was responsible
for the carnage in Oklahoma City, but he may have said this to protect
his co-conspirators.
Toward the end of his military service, McVeigh got involved with
a far-right crowd with extreme, anti-government views. It was the
early '90s, and the militia scene was starting to percolate. Nourished
by the odoriferous compost of paranoia and hate that has long moldered
on the American margins, McVeigh began making the rounds at gun
shows.
McVeigh immersed himself in the so-called "patriot movement," a
volatile subculture where the militias overlapped with the crazed
racist fringe. He joined a Ku Klux Klan group, read the Liberty
Lobby's Spotlight and mingled with members of the neo-Nazi
National Alliance, whose leader, William Pierce, wrote The Turner
Diaries. This notorious hate novel describes a successful paramilitary
insurgency by white supremacists who blow up a federal building
in Washington. It was McVeigh's favorite book, and it would serve
as a blueprint for the Oklahoma City bombing.
A paranoid style has always been part of the U.S. political scene,
along with right-wing paramilitary groups such as the KKK, the Minutemen,
and the Posse Comitatus. What distinguished the post-Cold-War patriot
movement from its predecessors was how it reinvented fascist ideology
in a uniquely American way by combining muddled arguments for anti-big-
government constitutionalism with traditional isolationist appeals,
reactionary conspiracy theories and frontier myths that promised
national regeneration through violence. Offering scapegoats rather
than solutions, the patriot subculture attracted deeply disenchanted
individuals with real, down-home gripes. Shunted aside while U.S.
corporations got leaner and meaner, many of these people were treading
water economically and aching for someone to blame.
With so many Americans taking the paramilitary oath, wacky ideas
began trickling down to millions of malcontents. The militias were
rife with wild rumors about government mind-control plots, Midwest
tornados caused by CIA weather modification, secret markings encoded
on the backs of road-signs to assist an imminent U.N. invasion.
After the Ruby Ridge shootout and the Waco conflagration, McVeigh
became convinced that the federal government was plotting to disarm
gun owners in order to pave the way for a takeover by a shadowy
elite of bankers, industrialists and politicians who ruled the new
world order. McVeigh decided to go on the offensive, hoping to spark
an insurrection. It is possible that he had help from the underground
Aryan Republican Army (ARA), a small group of gangsters and neo-Nazi
zealots who sought to overthrow the U.S. government, purge the country
of blacks and Jews, and install a new legal system based entirely
on their own racist interpretation of the Bible.
In the mid-'90s, the ARA robbed 22 banks in eight Midwest states.
Not without a sense of humor, the ARA bandits wore whimsical disguises,
such as Count Dracula and Ronald Reagan masks, while they pulled
off their bank heists. Some of the stolen money may have financed
McVeigh, who seemed to have an inordinate amount of cash for an
unemployed drifter. During this period, McVeigh told his sister
Jennifer that he had helped organize a bank robbery and he showed
her a wad of $100 bills, which he claimed was payment for his role
in the job. Richard Guthrie, an ARA bank robber who committed suicide
in jail, referred in his unpublished memoirs to an accomplice named
Tim.
Indiana State University criminologist Mark Hamm has discovered
a compelling connection between McVeigh's movements in the months
leading up to the Oklahoma City bombing and the shifting whereabouts
of the self-styled ARA guerrillas. They traveled in the same circles
and were often in the same place at the same time--a pattern that
is difficult to write off as mere coincidence.
The ARA used Elohim City, a remote, white supremacist enclave in
eastern Oklahoma, as a gathering point. McVeigh got a speeding ticket
a few miles from Elohim City, and telephone logs indicate that he
called the compound two weeks before the Oklahoma City attack. Carol
Howe, a paid undercover informant for the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco
and Firearms, later testified under oath that she saw McVeigh (a.k.a.
"Tim Tuttle") at Elohim City. She also claimed that she heard people
at Elohim City talking about bombing government buildings, but she
weakened her credibility by changing parts of her story on different
occasions.
All known ARA members are either dead or in prison, and their role,
if any, in the Oklahoma City massacre remains a mystery. But there
are those who still believe that the only way to right deep-rooted
wrongs is by setting a timer or pulling a trigger. The subculture
of hate that spawned McVeigh has survived his execution. 
Martin A. Lee is the author of The Beast Reawakens,
a book on neofascism.
|