How immigration is transforming our society.
The definition of terrorist has drifted far from ground zero.
The return of the culture wars.
The Angolan wars connection to suburban Arizona.
Market Magic's Empty Shell
Days of infamy and memory.
Let's review the tape.
The liberal media strike again.
Israels gravest danger is not the Palestinians.
Bush unilaterally junks the ABM accord.
Washington gives Indians the runaroundagain.
Mumia's death sentence is overturned, for now.
Massey Energy, Inc. targeted by labor and greens.
Phil Radford: Last Call, Save the Ales.
BOOKS: Empires new clothes.
The Empty Theater
BOOKS: Joan Didion vs. the political class.
BOOKS: The Complete Works of Isaac Babel.
FILM: The Devils Backbone of the Spanish Civil War.
December 22, 2001
The Arms Dealer Next Door
International billionaire, French prisoner, Angolan weapons broker, Arizona Republican. Who is Pierre Falcone?
n December 1, billionaire businessman Pierre Falcone walked out of the Fleury-Merogis prison near Paris after a judge opted not to prolong his provisional detention. Despite having spent a full year behind bars, its doubtful that Falcone felt a great sense of relief that day.
The key player in a huge scandal that has tarnished some of Frances best-known politicians, Falcone is still expected to stand trial later this year for his role in the sale of half a billion dollars worth of Eastern European weapons to Angola. He obtained his release only after paying a $15 million bail, turning over his passport to the court, and accepting severe restrictions on his movements and activities.
Falcone was initially charged with illegal arms dealing because he allegedly brokered the Angola sales without authorization from the French government agency that reviews weapons exports, but prosecutors later dropped that count due to a legal technicality. He remains accused of bribing numerous prominent parties to further his arms businessmost notably Jean-Christophe Mitterand, son of ex-President Francois Mitterandand of failing to pay tens of millions of dollars in taxes on profits from the Angola deals, legal or not.
Though largely unreported, the man at the center of Angolagate, as the French press has dubbed the scandal, has extensive American ties. Falcones primary residence is a mammoth estate in Paradise Valley, Arizona, where he and his wife, Sonia, a former Miss Bolivia International, are active in political and community affairs. Falcones American activities range from advising a major U.S. oil company to teaming with a Virginia-based arms dealer who has worked for both the CIA and Saddam Hussein. Whats more, a floundering health and beauty company run by Sonia Falcone made a controversial $100,000 donation to the Republican Party during the 2000 presidential campaign.
Beyond Falcones own stake in the legal outcome, Angolagate has significant geopolitical implications. Angola has emerged as one of the worlds leading oil producersit is now Americas ninth-largest supplier, ahead of Kuwait and England and right behind Norway and Colombiaand is sitting on enormous untapped reserves. But civil war and rampant corruption in Angola, which serves as the backdrop to the Falcone affair, has kept the country isolated on the international stage and its economy in shambles. Angola is going to remain a pariah as long as the government keeps cutting deals with people like Falcone, says a former State Department official who has closely followed Angolagate. It sends a terrible message to the rest of Africa, because if Angola cant make it with all of its energy resources, theres not much hope for the rest of the continent.
hen I first heard about Pierre Falconeand his beautiful Bolivian wife, vast wealth and jet-setting lifestyleI imagined a dapper, handsome man straight out of a John Le Carré novel. It came as something of a surprise when I first saw his picture, which revealed him to be a plump, balding man who looked more like an upscale insurance salesman than a covert operator.
Falcone was born in 1954 in Algeria, which was then under French rule. His father, Pierre Sr., was the mayor of a town called Bou-Haroun-Alger, ran a fishing fleet and, according to Le Monde, was involved in the arms trade. After the Algerian Revolution of 1962, the family moved to France, where Falcone lived until he was 22. Since then, he has traveled the world, building a business empire that runs from advertising in China to oil in Africa.
Falcone bought a home in Arizona in the 80s and met Sonia Montero at a 1990 Formula One auto race in Phoenix. They were married four years later at a church outside of Paris. Hundreds of guests attended the wedding and receptionthe latter was held at the Chateau de Ferrieres, the 19th-century home of the Rothschildsincluding the grooms good friend, Jean-Christophe Mitterand.
The arms trade comprises a small, if notable, part of Falcones commercial activities. In France, he served as a consultant to a government agency known as SOFREMI, which exports military equipment under the auspices of the Interior Ministry. In that capacity, he reportedly arranged sales to Africa and Latin America. Through Arcadi Gaydamakan immensely wealthy Russian émigré businessman and his chief partner in AngolaFalcone also had good contacts in Eastern Europe, which in the post-Cold War period has become a global weapons bazaar.
The deals that sparked the Angolagate scandal took place in 1993, when the Angolan government of Eduardo dos Santos was under siege by the right-wing guerrilla group known as UNITA, headed by Jonas Savimbi. During the Cold War, Angola could count on the Soviet Union for weaponsUNITA had been backed by Presidents Reagan and Bush, but was dumped by the Clinton administrationbut its former ally had disappeared from the map. Furthermore, arms purchases by the government and UNITA remained prohibited under the 1991 Bicesse Accords negotiated in Portugal. Desperate, dos Santos contacted Jean-Bernard Curial, a friend and member of the French Socialist Party, to see if Paris would arm his regime.
Curial was dubious about the prospects. France was then in a period of political cohabitation with Socialist Francois Mitterand (who died in 1996) holding the presidency, but day-to-day governing was carried out by conservative Prime Minister Eduardo Balladur. Several key members of Balladurs government, including the minister of defense, traditionally had been close to UNITA. Curial turned for advice to Jean-Christophe Mitterand, who had built up a network of contacts in Africa while serving as his fathers chief adviser and, despite having resigned his post the previous year, remained well-connected at the presidential palace. He suggested to Curial that his friend Falcone might be able to offer assistance to dos Santos through less formal channels.
n November 1993, Falcone and Gaydamak helped arrange the sale to Angola of $47 million in small arms. A second deal for $563 million worth of weapons, including tanks and helicopters, got underway early the following year. The supplier in both cases was ZTS-OSOS, a Slovakian company that rounded up the weapons from Russia, Bulgaria and Ukraine. The Angolans paid for the weapons with oil, which Falcone and Gaydamak sold with the help of Glencorea company owned by Marc Rich, the fugitive financier who would later receive a controversial pardon from Bill Clinton during his last days as president.
Thanks to their sensitive role in Angola, Falcone and Gaydamak became intimate cronies of dos Santos, whose systematic pilfering of the state treasury has made him by some accounts one of the worlds 50 richest men. (On December 12, Reuters reported that $1.5 billion of the $3.5 billion that Angola earned in 2000 from oil exports was unaccounted for.) The two men were given a stake in virtually every key sector of the Angolan economy, from food to diamonds to oil. In 1999, the government picked Falcon Oil Holdings, a Falcone-owned firm registered in Panama, as a minority partner to ExxonMobil on a huge offshore site.
Beyond these economic privileges, Falcone and Gaydamak gained a remarkable degree of political influence in Angola. According to Gaydamaka wanted man in France who now resides in Israel, where I reached him on his cell phoneboth he and Falcone were granted Angolan citizenship and diplomatic passports, served as advisers to the government and were named employees of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Indeed, Falcone was so well-connected in Angola that before his arrest he had become a door-opener for companies hoping to do business there. In June 2000, top officials from Phillips Petroleum, which has been seeking to expand in Angola, made the pilgrimage from corporate headquarters in Bartlesville, Oklahoma to Arizona to seek Falcones counsel and assistance. (Phillips declined to discuss the meeting.)
The first vague details of Angolagate came to light five years ago when a highly regarded insider newsletter called La Lettre du Continent broke the story. French judicial officials later found that Brenco International, a Falcone firm involved in the Angola arms transfers, subsequently made payments to a number of his associates. Jean-Christophe Mitterand, who has been out on bail since early last year but remains under investigation, acknowledges receiving $1.8 million into his numbered Swiss bank account four years ago, but says that the money was for consulting work unrelated to Angolan arms sales.
Theres surely an element of hypocrisy in the French governments prosecution of Falcone, for its clear that key officials viewed his arms transfers to Angola as serving French foreign policy objectives and approved of the deals. France depends on Africa for most of its petroleum needs, but traditional suppliers like Gabon and Cameroon have declining reserves. Angolaset to become one of the worlds major petroleum exporters in the next 20 yearshas not traditionally had strong ties to France, but in recent years it has become an increasingly important source of its oil, and French energy companies have been awarded major contracts by the dos Santos regime. There is a relationship between Falcone selling the weapons and the improved relationship between France and Angola, says Sharon Coutoux of Survie, a Paris-based human rights group.
Falcone, too, has suggested that the French government endorsed his activities. In a 14-page letter to investigators, he denied paying off any government officials, saying his role in the Angolan arms sales was limited to selling the oil that paid for the weapons. The greatest indignity of all, he wrote, is that the French are the primary beneficiary of his activities. His work with SOFREMI enabled Paris to penetrate delicate and complex markets abroad, while his role in Angola helped France win favor with an energy-rich regime that the entire world is interested in courting. The accusations against him, Falcone said, are as unjust as the charge of witchcraft [was] in the Middle Ages.
n Washington, Falcones complex ties in Angola were well known among government Africa specialists. Four past and present officials told me they were acquainted with Falcone via diplomatic cables and intelligence reports. J. Stephen Morrison, who served on the secretary of states policy-planning staff until last year, says Clinton administration officials were aware that Falcone was a key player in Angola and that most of what he did was not very transparent. The scandal caught people by surprise, but it was not a big shock.
Falcones name is also familiar within the narrow world of international arms dealers. Sarkis Soghanalian, whose 40-year career in the arms business began when he armed Christian militias in Lebanon at the request of the CIA, says he met Falcone several times in Paris, where both had offices off the Champs-Elysées. Through Mark Geragos, his American attorney (whose other clients include Rep. Gary Condit), Soghanalian said that he and Falcone shared a mutual client, Mobutu Sese Seko, the former dictator of Zaire (now the Democratic Republic of the Congo). According to Soghanalian, Falcone brokered diamonds-for-weapons deals on behalf of Mobutu and was intimate with the dictator and his entourage.
Among Falcones closest contacts in the arms business is Stephen Satch Baumgart, who operates out of Reston, Virginia. A former Naval officer, Baumgart has been involved in the murkier fringes of the weapons trade since the 70s, when he brokered sales to American allies such as Mobutu and Ferdinand Marcos in the Philippinesall apparently with a wink and a nod from U.S. intelligence. A CIA agent would drop by our office and Baumgart would brief him about his overseas travels, particularly about his contacts in the Arab world, recalls Gerhard Bauch, a one-time German intelligence officer who worked for Baumgart. They knew about everything we did.
During the mid-80s, Baumgartwho did not return phone calls seeking commenthelped supply Saddam Hussein, who was then seen by the Reagan administration as a bulwark against the Ayatollah Khomeini in Iran. A prominent European arms broker who knows both Falcone and Baumgart says the two men first teamed up in the 80s and worked together until at least a few years ago. This source says that Falcone and Baumgart had interests in Angola, among other places. (Gaydamak also confirms that Falcone and Mr. Satch worked together, though he denied knowing details of their business dealings.)
f it was an open secret in certain Washington circles, Falcones involvement in the arms trade was entirely unknown in Paradise Valley, an elite enclave wedged between Phoenix and Scottsdale. Reginald Ballantyne III, president of PMH Health Resources Inc., says the Falcones are highly regarded local figures and that he and other residents were stunned when Angolagate hit the press. It didnt make any sense to me then, and it still doesnt make any sense to me, Ballantyne said. I just couldnt connect the dots.
One of the nations wealthiest communities, Paradise Valley is solidly conservative. The local government levies no property taxes, and services such as water and fire protection have been privatized. I received a tour of the town from Kathy Smith of Hague Partners, which sold $103 million worth of property here last year. As we drove along Lincoln Road in Smiths cream-colored Cadillac, we passed one of the towns few commercial properties, the newly renovated Applewood pet resort, where residents board their pets when theyre on vacation. A suite for a dog, which includes a bed and cable TV, goes for $38 a night, but extrasa fitness walk, pupsicles, a swim in the resorts bone-shaped pool, topped off with a blow drycan raise that rate quite a bit higher.
Far atop Mummy Mountain, Smith pointed to the estate of Leona Helmsley, which has been on the market for several years without attracting a buyer, despite a price cut from $24 million to $14 million. Smith used a magnetic card to pass through the gates of the El Maro neighborhood, where Chicago Bulls owner Jerry Reinsdorf erected a private playground for his grandchildren on a two-acre lot adjacent to his summer home. Just before his arrest, Falcone bought a new $10.6 million estate not far from the El Maro sectionthe most expensive home purchase in state history, according to the Arizona Republic. A post-sale real estate listing speaks in hushed tones of the propertys paneled library, theater, swimming pool, tennis courts, seven bedrooms and 11 bathrooms, and reveals that the Falcones dont have a mortgage on the property. It was purchased outright by SPEP, a Turk and Caicos Island trust controlled by Pierre.
As members of the areas upper crust, the Falcones occasionally pop up in local society pages. Based on nuggets that ran after Falcones arrest, their standing has not been tarnished by his legal difficulties. In the April 2001 issue of Arizona Trends, a magazine filled with ads for Feng Shui consultants, plastic surgeons, anti-aging treatments and day spas, then-publisher Danny Medina recounted his lunch with Sonia Falcone: She was perfectly stunning with a great personality and rich, rich, rich. Oy! You should have seen the square cut diamond on her hand!
In May, Scottsdale Life, a glossy freebie sent to selected area homes with an assessed value of $250,000 or more, featured a cover story on the Falcones new estate. It spoke of bedroom suites that bear the imprimatur of Sonias exquisite taste, of the Vera Wang evening gowns hanging in her 1,100-square-foot closet, and of her devotion to family and friends. (And, yes, it does help to have a butler, cook, domestic help, chauffeurs and an army of nannies to help out.)
Like many Paradise Valley residents, the Falcones are regulars on the local black-tie charity circuit and contribute generously to organizations such as the American Heart Association, Phoenix Childrens Memorial Center and the Kids in a Korner Foundation. During my stay in Arizona, Sonia attended a fundraiser for the American Cancer Society at Marriotts Camelback Inn resort. After dining on pinenut-crusted filet of beef and wild-mushroom risotto, attendees bid at auction on donated items such as a week at the Hacienda del Mar in Cabo San Lucas, a variety of golfing packages and diamond jewelry.
Sonia, who declined to be interviewed for this story, was accompanied to the fundraiser by Jason Rose, a Phoenix PR man and Republican political consultant whom she has retained to tell her husbands side of the Angolagate story. The son of a prominent area family, Rose is a rising star in GOP circles. He knows the Falcones from local social and political circles (Theyre cool people who youd like to have a drink with) and argues that Pierre is the victim of a French legal system that deems people guilty until proven innocent.
n addition to charity, the Falcones have also taken an interest in politics. In June 2000, the couple hosted a fundraiser at their home for Scott Bundgaard, a Republican state senator and close ally of President Bush. (Bundgaard endorsed Bush over native son John McCain during last years GOP primaries and was a major fundraiser for his campaign.) The affair attracted political luminaries such as Gov. Jane Hull and several members of Arizonas congressional delegation, as well as Jean-Christophe Mitterand.
Sonia Falcone was also a donor to the Bush campaign, and pictures of her with the president and first lady, snapped at political functions in Arizona, hang in her home. During the summer of 2000, Bundgaard invited Sonia to join a small local entourage that greeted then candidate Bush at the Phoenix airport when he flew in for a campaign event. Most of Sonias political contributions came from the coffers of Essante, her Utah-based health and beauty firm. The company gave $20,000 to the Republican Party in May 2000 and another $80,000 in November. Sonia Falcone has insisted that her husband had no connection to Essante and that the companys political contributions came out of corporate profits. She made the donations, she says, to increase Latino awareness in the Republican Party. (The GOP returned the contributions following Pierres detentionto avoid the appearance of impropriety, in the words of a statement issued by the Republican National Committee.)
Yet Essante was incorporated in Delaware on April 6, 1994 with Sonia as its founding president and one of two directorsthe other was Pierre Falcone. He no longer holds that title, but the firms accountant until just recently was Henry Guderley, who fills the same position for the London offices of Brenco International. More significantly, Essante, which has been losing money for the past seven years, has no profits from which to make political contributions. Essante publicist Lee Soltersa legendary Hollywood PR agent whose clients have included everyone from Frank Sinatra and Barbra Streisand to Pia Zadora and Kato Kaelinsays Essante spent its first six years, and $6 million, developing its product line. Sales only began in earnest last September, after Essante threw a three-day launch party at the Paris Hotel in Las Vegas.
So whos been footing the bill? A source familiar with the company says Pierre has always provided the money for Essante. The company has come a long way with Pierres generosity, but after a few years hed like to see some profit, this person says. It rubs him the wrong way, but out of love for his wife hes done it with a smile on his face.
Its possible that Essantes political contributions were spurred by nothing more than Sonias open desire to be a player in state and national politics. Even after her husbands arrest, she remains active on the Arizona scene and close to several state officials. Last June, Bundgaard accompanied her and several other friends to Washington for a gala affair at the Ritz-Carlton honoring Sharon Stone. A few months later, Sonia appeared at a campaign function for Matt Salmon, an Arizona congressman whos running for governor on the GOP ticket. She called him a true conservative and said she planned to help his campaign any way I can.
But one of the American officials I interviewed suspects that Pierre may have been thinking about Angolas interests when his wife sent $100,000 to the GOP. As the official noted, businessmen who operate in Angola are expected to support its government back home, and Luanda is eager to cement ties to Washington, which during the Clinton years became its chief international ally and biggest source of foreign investment. Furthermore, dos Santos has reason to be jittery about the policies of George W. Bush, whose fathers supported UNITA. In February 2000, just weeks after Bushs inauguration and a few months after Essante sent its final payment to the RNC, two major lobby shops in WashingtonPatton Boggs and Daniel J. Edelman signed contracts that called for them to work to improve U.S.-Angola ties.
Of course, only Falcone himself can offer a full explanation of why his money went to the Bush campaign. Given his current circumstances, chances are he wont be talking anytime soon.
Ken Silverstein is a Washington-based reporter who frequently writes about the arms trade. His latest book, Private Warriors, a look at the post-Cold War arms trade, was just released in paperback.