Farmer’s Clever Case Against Monsanto Didn’t Sway Supreme Court

Amien Essif

After a preliminary Supreme Court hearing in Bowman v. Monsanto Company yesterday, the Washington Post reports that the justices may be preparing to once again uphold the right of corporations to patent a living thing and its offspring: Questions from the justices during oral arguments indicated that they agreed with the contention of Monsanto and other companies that research and development would dry up if the companies’ patents were easily circumvented. “Why in the world would anybody spend any money to try to improve the seed if as soon as they sold the first one anybody could grow more and have as many of those seeds as they want?” Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. asked. After Indiana farmer Harry Bowman planted Monsanto’s genetically modified Roundup Ready bean among his feed soybeans, the bio-tech giant sued him in 2007 on the grounds of patent violation. Now, Mother Jones reports, the case had made its way to the Supreme Court, where the justices have so far taken Monsanto’s side that Bowman was manufacturing a patented invention. Bowman’s lawyer, however is countering with “patent exhaustion”—in other words, that Monsanto’s patent on the seeds cannot determine how farmers use the next generation of sprouts. In fact, the court has never considered patent exhaustion in the context of self-replicating technologies. Bowman carefully exploited a seeming loophole in Monsanto's rigid protections on the use of its seeds. Grist reports: There is one tiny crack in Monsanto’s legal fortress. The company allows farmers to sell saved seeds from harvests of Roundup Ready crops to local grain elevators…. The grain elevators mix the seeds up with other seeds from brand-name hybrids and resell them as generic seed packs, called “commodity seeds” in the trade, which are often used for late-season “second crop” planting. This argument is unlikely to be upheld by a court with a history of defending Monsanto. But it may score a smaller victory against Monsanto by bringing into public scrutiny the ethics of owning not just seeds, but their offspring.

Help In These Times Celebrate & Have Your Gift Matched!

In These Times is proud to share that we were recently awarded the 16th Annual Izzy Award from the Park Center for Independent Media at Ithaca College. The Izzy Award goes to an independent outlet, journalist or producer for contributions to culture, politics or journalism created outside traditional corporate structures.

Fellow 2024 Izzy awardees include Trina Reynolds-Tyler and Sarah Conway for their joint investigative series “Missing In Chicago," and journalists Mohammed El-Kurd and Lynzy Billing. The Izzy judges also gave special recognition to Democracy Now! for coverage that documented the destruction wreaked in Gaza and raised Palestinian voices to public awareness.

In These Times is proud to stand alongside our fellow awardees in accepting the 2024 Izzy Award. To help us continue producing award-winning journalism a generous donor has pledged to match any donation, dollar-for-dollar, up to $20,000.

Will you help In These Times celebrate and have your gift matched today? Make a tax-deductible contribution to support independent media.

Amien Essif is a regular contributor to Working In These Times and maintains a blog called The Gazine, which focuses on consumerism, gentrification, and technology with a Luddite bent. His work has also appeared on the Guardian and CounterPunch. You can find him using Twitter reluctantly: @AmienChicago
The War on Protest Cover
Get 10 issues for $19.95

Subscribe to the print magazine.