David Kurtz at TPM quotes from a government directory known as the "Plum Book," to which Cheney's office submitted this entry in lieu of a list of its employees, as federal agencies must do: The Vice Presidency is a unique office that is neither a part of the executive branch nor a part of the legislative branch, but is attached by the Constitution to the latter. The Vice Presidency performs functions in both the legislative branch (see article I, section 3 of the Constitution) and in the executive branch (see article II, and amendments XII and XXV, of the Constitution and section 106 of title 3 of the United States Code). neither
1 : not either
2 : also not
One might have thought it could go without saying that, had the founders considered the Vice President not to be a part either of the executive or legislative branch, they would have crafted an additional Article to distinguish the job description, as Articles I, II, and III each define the legislative, executive and judiciary branches. By definition - it apparently does need be said - the text of the Constitution plainly spells out functions of the VP to be performed in both executive and legislative arenas of government. And ergo of course the VP is "a part" of both branches. Cheney's characterization defies elementary reading comprehension.
It is noteworthy that Cheney goes through this exercise of distortion to separate the office of VP from the executive branch, and to give greater significant weight to the legislative powers of the office: "The Vice Presidency is a unique office that is neither a part of the executive branch nor a part of the legislative branch, but is attached by the Constitution to the latter." And this despite the text of the title 3 code, cited in the paragraph, crafted explicitly "to enable the Vice President to provide assistance to the President." Plus the cite is truly baffling, given that what it addresses primarily are issues of money - salaries, fees, expenditures, for entertainment, travel and subsistence - related to the VP's spouse and family.
It's rather quite a different view of the job than that held by John Nance Garner.
More articles by Brian Zick
FBI Director Mueller Contradicts Gonzales
Brian Zick
Democrats Request Special Counsel Be Appointed to Investigate Perjury Charges Against Gonzales
Brian Zick
Rove and Deputy Jennings Subpoenaed by Senate Judiciary Committee
Brian Zick
Announcing In These Times’ New Agreement with the National Writers Union
Freelance contributors are essential to the quality and success of In These Times and independent media, and this agreement is one way to demonstrate their value to our publication and our commitment to transparency.
For more information about the National Writers Union, visit nwu.org.
Read the full agreement, which reaffirms a floor for the rates of our freelance editorial content, as well as our current rates (which are higher) and submissions guidelines below.