Workers Who Make Chicago’s Transit Seats Want One at the Negotiation Table

Freedman Seating has collected millions in public support and touts its second-chance hiring. Workers say the jobs leave them stuck, and they want a binding agreement that gives them a voice.

J. Patrick Patterson

People hold signs outside Freedman Seating Company on Chicago’s West Side. The company manufactures seats for public transit. PHOTO BY PAUL GOYETTE

CHICAGO—On the city’s deindustrialized West Side, the more-than-century-old Freedman Seating Company is one of the largest remaining manufacturing firms, employing more than 700 workers to make seats for city buses and trains. 

But despite the company’s storied past — and millions of dollars in public support and contracts — labor advocates say it’s failing to provide real economic opportunity for community members. 

On Oct. 21, a group of labor organizers and allies tried delivering a letter to Freedman’s leadership, demanding they sit down and negotiate a deal for workers.

After a few knocks at the door, a company representative answered but refused to accept the letter. She did, however, agree to reach out within 10 days, according to Edie Jacobs. 

Jacobs, director of Get to Work, an organization that connects West Side residents with local jobs, was at the front of the group. ​“If we don’t hear from them in 10 days, then we got to come back,” she told In These Times in the parking lot.

The letter asks Freedman to negotiate a community benefits agreement (CBA), a legally binding deal between a company and community and labor groups.

“We want to make sure Freedman is a real opportunity for workers on the West Side of Chicago, an area where too few of our people are able to access stable, gainful employment,” the authors write.

Freedman has a reputation in the community for hiring people coming out of prison. Organizers, researchers and workers say that reputation conceals a harsher reality: People from disadvantaged backgrounds — ones with records, in particular — have few places to go, and that makes them easy to exploit.

About 35 people had assembled that afternoon in Augusta Park, on the West Side, to announce a campaign to win a CBA for Freedman workers. Many belong to the Good Work Coalition, a group of local community organizations, religious leaders and labor groups.

“We want to make sure Freedman is a real opportunity for workers on the West Side of Chicago, an area where too few of our people are able to access stable, gainful employment."

Freedman’s workers ​“are subjected to low wages and hazardous working conditions with no voice to fix it,” said Leone Jose Bicchieri, founder of Working Family Solidarity, at the rally. ​“We want a binding agreement that creates real partnership with the community for local hire, training and for workers to have a fair process to organize a union without fear of retaliation.”

Lippert Components bought Freedman in April 2025. Federal antitrust regulators are now reviewing a proposed merger between Lippert’s parent company, LCI Industries, and Patrick Industries. The Justice Department requested additional documents from both companies on Oct. 9, a step beyond initial review that extends the waiting period. Shareholders of both firms are scheduled to vote on the deal Nov. 18. 

People assemble in Augusta Park, on Oct 21, on Chicago’s West Side, to announce a campaign to win a CBA for Freedman workers. Many belong to the Good Work Coalition, a group of local community organizations, religious leaders and labor groups. PHOTO BY PAUL GOYETTE

LOW WAGES, SAFETY ISSUES, NO VOICE

The march followed the release of a report from Jobs to Move America (JMA), a national policy and research organization. The report, published in October, documents low wages, hazardous working conditions, limited opportunities for growth and lack of employee voice. 

JMA’s research — completed in collaboration with the University of Illinois at Chicago’s Center for Urban Economic Development — includes survey responses from 116 Freedman manufacturing workers.

“You have to work overtime nonstop and slave yourself to be able to afford living,” says Max, a current Freedman worker who spoke with In These Times outside the facility. He asked to use a pseudonym to protect him from employer retaliation.

The factory is located on Chicago’s West Side, a largely Black and Latino area affected by historic disinvestment. Its workforce includes welders, polishers and sewers, among other positions.

“You have to work overtime nonstop and slave yourself to be able to afford living."

Max works with metal to help make seats for the company’s transit market. As a grinder and polisher, he’s exposed to airborne metal dust and debris, including carbon, silica from the abrasive belts and ​“hex chrome six,” or hexavalent chromium, an extremely toxic chemical applied to metal to prevent rust.

“There are filter machines,” says Max, ​“but since I’ve started working in that department, I’ve been told that they don’t even work.”

Sign up for our weekend newsletter
A weekly digest of our best coverage

In 2019, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration issued two serious citations to the company for failing to provide adequate chemical hazard training, including how to safely work with hexavalent chromium. Initial penalties of $11,366 were reduced to $7,000 in an informal settlement, according to public records.

Working with hexavalent chromium without proper training or safety gear can lead to serious long-term health issues, including lung cancer, eye damage, liver and kidney damage and asthma attacks.

Some workers surveyed by JMA also reported that the lack of air conditioning in the summer makes it difficult to wear masks. Eighty-one percent noticed at least one hazard in the past year, such as water reaching electrical equipment and welding machine cords held together with ​“many, many layers of electrical tape.” A polisher quoted in the report spoke of ​“worn out tools” that make it difficult to hit requested quotas. ​“Superiors don’t listen to concerns we voice to avoid complications ahead of time,” the worker said.

Freedman did not address specific questions about safety from In These Times, but said in a statement that, ​“Safety remains a top priority, supported by robust training, reporting, and environmental health and safety programs.” The company also says it encourages ​“open communication” and provides ​“multiple avenues for employees to raise questions, share feedback, and voice concerns without fear of retaliation.” 

On Oct. 21, coalition members knocked on Freedman’s offices to deliver a letter asking the company to negotiate a community benefits agreement for workers. The letter was not accepted. PHOTOS BY PAUL GOYETTE

PUBLIC MONEY, PRIVATE OWNERS

Freedman has benefited from millions in state and local subsidies. In January 2024, the company received $11 million in tax credits from the Chicago Development Fund to buy and improve a 263,400-square-foot building and expand its manufacturing operation. In November 2024, it won renewed Cook County property tax relief and a state tax credit agreement tied to 50 new jobs and 676 retained ones.

“As a major Chicago manufacturer that serves public-sector customers and has benefited from taxpayer-supported incentives and financing,” the report’s author writes, ​“Freedman has a particular responsibility to provide jobs that deliver meaningful economic opportunity to workers and the surrounding community.”

Freedman has benefited from millions in state and local subsidies, and coalition members want enforceable commitments around the quality of its jobs. PHOTO BY PAUL GOYETTE

The company has kept its doors open throughout several waves of plant closures that have swept the city. ​“But is that the best that we can expect from them for the public contracts and the tax incentives that we dole out? That they just stay open and exist?” asked Marcos Feldman, senior researcher at JMA and author of the report, at the rally. ​“All of that public support makes the quality of the jobs back here at this factory a matter of public concern.”

Feldman says the community would also benefit from more scrutiny of Freedman itself as it enters this new phase. ​“Public support for manufacturing shouldn’t just preserve those jobs, but also has to improve, monitor, and enforce job quality,” he says. ​“Continued public support has to be tied to clear, enforceable commitments around the quality of those jobs.”

"Public support for manufacturing shouldn't just preserve those jobs, but also has to improve, monitor, and enforce job quality."

Freedman workers tried organizing in 2019, but the company’s campaign helped defeat the effort, Feldman told In These Times. Department of Labor filings show Freedman signed a May 2019 agreement with LRI Consulting Services for ​“pre-petition campaign consulting,” a service whose stated goals included preventing petitions for a union election. Freedman reported paying LRI nearly $65,000 that year.

The company did not respond to specific questions about previous organizing efforts, but said in its statement that it ​“has been a committed member of Chicago’s West Side business community for more than 30 years, and JMA’s recent report does not accurately reflect our workplace culture, values, or the experience of our employees.” 

After being ushered away from the office by a security guard, coalition members march a few blocks around the corner to where workers arrive for their shift to pass out flyers about the CBA demand. PHOTO BY PAUL GOYETTE

A SECOND CHANCE?

Freedman is widely recognized for its long-standing ​“fair-chance” or ​“second-chance” programs, through which it hires formerly incarcerated people. Around 30% of the workers surveyed by JMA were formerly incarcerated or involved in reentry or parole programs.

“Consistent with our longstanding commitment to local hiring and fair-chance employment, we invest in our people through competitive wages and benefits, training, and opportunities for advancement,” Freedman told In These Times.

“It sounds great,” said Jacobs at the rally, ​“but what’s the real story?” A retired probation officer, she’s spent years finding jobs for West Siders. ​“It’s not a real chance if you can’t even pay people enough to live.”

Felix, another pseudonym, has worked for Freedman for more than a decade and says his $21/​hour pay is not enough to get by. ​“People are basically trying to make ends meet. They’re living paycheck to paycheck. Sometimes the paycheck doesn’t even last a full week. Mine doesn’t.”

Managers have brought up workers’ records on the factory floor, according to Felix: ​“They’ll tell them, ​‘Good luck trying to find another job. You have a record.’” He says he has gone to HR about comments like this and was dismissed. 

“They’ll tell them, ‘Good luck trying to find another job. You have a record.’”

“They make it so very obvious that we’re not listened to.”

Feldman says that vulnerability is actually the point. A stigma attached to records limits where people can work, he says, weakening their bargaining power and keeping them trapped in low-wage work. ​“And they kind of take advantage of that,” says Feldman. ​“We know that they get tax breaks for hiring formerly incarcerated folks as a federal program, so they have their incentive to hire these folks, but they can’t go anywhere else.”

“Your wages, according to the data we collected, really only go up $1 or $2, which is nothing compared to inflation,” he adds. ​“There’s no forward advancement in your career, and you’re kind of stuck. … It doesn’t seem like a real second chance.”

Research on the federal subsidy behind many fair-chance programs points in a similar direction. A 2025 Brookings Institution report found that the Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC), which pays employers up to $2,400 per qualifying worker, does not meaningfully influence who gets hired. ​“Large employers regularly hire lots of workers for low-wage jobs, and in the process, hire WOTC qualifying workers totally by accident,” the report found. In other words, a handful of corporations receive millions of dollars for employing workers they would have hired anyway.

Legal scholar Noah Katz writes in Inquest that ​“carceral labor is not a problem confined to the prison.” He describes a ​“carceral labor continuum” in which the prison system’s influence extends into the conventional labor market. For Felix and his coworkers, that influence has shown up in offhand managerial warnings on the shop floor.

Workers and organizers across the country have benefited from CBAs, legally binding deals between companies and community and labor groups. PHOTO BY PAUL GOYTETTE

FIGHTING FOR A BETTER DEAL

Workers and organizers across the country have benefited from CBAs, and the coalition points to some of them as models.

In Chicago, a coalition signed a 2016 CBA with CRRC Sifang America, a railcar manufacturer that was building a plant on the city’s Southeast Side to assemble train cars for the Chicago Transit Authority. As part of the agreement, the company created a hiring pipeline for residents facing barriers to employment.

In Alabama, community and labor groups negotiated a 2022 agreement with bus manufacturer New Flyer. The company committed to hiring at least 45% of new workers from historically disadvantaged groups, including people with criminal records. New Flyer agreed to stay neutral during unionization efforts. In 2024, workers at the Anniston, Ala., plant ratified a first union contract providing for raises of 15 – 38%, more paid time off, improved parental leave and better retirement benefits, among other wins.

Chicago built its reputation on steel, rail and meatpacking and on fights for workers’ rights. It was here, in 1886, that a strike for the eight-hour day led to the Haymarket affair, an event that gave rise to International Workers’ Day, or May Day.

Outside the facility, coalition members set up an inflatable Fat Cat, a cousin of Scabby the Rat, holding money in one fist and choking a worker with the other. PHOTO BY PAUL GOYETTE

“Behind the walls of Freedman Seating, there are men and women who show up every day and do what working people have always done in this city,” said Bret Rocchietti, organizer for Sheet Metal Workers’ Local Union 73, at the rally. ​“They build. They weld. They fabricate. … Today we are here because the people who build those products are asking for something every worker deserves: a voice, a fair shot, and dignity on the job.”

After being ushered away from the office by a security guard, the group walked a few blocks around the corner to where workers arrive for their shift. They set up an inflatable Fat Cat, a cousin of Scabby the Rat, holding money in one fist and choking a worker with the other.

Organizers passed out flyers as workers came and went. Cars, trucks and fire engines honked while passing by. People gathered on either side of the driveway in front of chain-link fences topped with barbed wire, and others crossed Chicago Avenue to line the sidewalk with their signs from the rally.

Some cars sped away, eager to leave the lot, but many accepted a flyer explaining the CBA demand.

As of publication, a spokesperson for JMA says Freedman has made no effort to meet with the coalition. 

“my biweekly tonic” —Studs Terkel

Thank you for reading this story. At a time when corporate media is dominating the web and our airwaves, independent journalism is more important than ever, and that’s what we provide at In These Times. We offer some of the best reporting, investigations and analysis on the growing movements for justice in the U.S.—and our work is firmly pro-labor and anti-fascist. To continue producing it, we need your support.

If you believe in the power of an independent press, please make a donation to In These Times today. By becoming a sustaining member, you can ensure that our work reaches even more readers.

And if you become a sustainer right now, you'll get a free year-long print subscription and a special subscribers-only print from artist Molly Crabapple.

Thank you.

J. Patrick Patterson is the news editor at In These Times. He has previously worked as a politics editor, copy editor, fact-checker and reporter. His writing on economic policies and electoral politics has been published in numerous outlets.

Get 10 issues for $19.95

Subscribe to the print magazine.