Tribal Court Case Against Line 3 Pipeline Is First to Invoke “Rights of Nature”

The suit by the White Earth Band of Ojibwe says Enbridge’s pipeline would violate the rights of wild rice, which the tribe enshrined in law in 2018.

Alex Brown

Members of the Leech Lake Band of Ojibwe harvest wild rice in 2015. Photo courtesy of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

Editor’s Note: This article was originally published by Stateline, an initiative of The Pew Charitable Trusts.

In what is believed to be the first tribal court case brought under the rights of nature” legal doctrine, the White Earth Band of Ojibwe in Minnesota has filed an action in its court system on behalf of manoomin (wild rice) to stop billions of gallons of water from being diverted for an oil pipeline.

In 2018, the tribe enshrined in its law the right of manoomin to exist, flourish, regenerate and evolve” — part of a growing movement led by Indigenous people to give legal rights to nature and to change its status as property. The tribe argues that the diversion of 5 billion gallons of groundwater for the construction of Enbridge’s Line 3 oil pipeline would violate manoomin’s rights.

This is a daring move,” said tribal attorney Frank Bibeau. We’re doing something that hasn’t been done.”

Critics have argued that recognizing rights of nature would make businesses and governments vulnerable to lawsuits over almost any action with an impact on the environment.

Meanwhile, the tribal leaders say the oil company’s permit also violates their treaty rights, which promise tribal members can gather wild rice. In recent years, tribes have increasingly used their treaty-guaranteed rights to hunt, fish and gather as a legal tool to protect the ecosystems on which those customs rely

Wild rice is the center of our culture,” Bibeau said. Wild rice is what brought us to the Great Lakes. We cannot allow the state of Minnesota to continue to undercut and sell us out.”

According to Bibeau, the state is seeking to dismiss the case for lack of jurisdiction, but he believes treaty rights give tribal members the ability to press the case.

A lot of the territory that’s being crossed [by the pipeline] is public forest and public waters, and those are the primary places where we exercise our rights to hunt, fish and gather,” he said. Our treaty foods are dependent on abundant, high-quality water.”

Join Our Rural America Newsletter
Fearless journalism, emailed straight to you.

The lawsuit asks the tribal court to issue an injunction against the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources to void the water permit issued by the agency. Bibeau said that state officials would be unlikely to follow a decision issued by a tribal court, but starting the case there could help fast-track a decision in federal court.

If the tribe succeeds, Bibeau said it could be a landmark case that further strengthens tribal claims to protect ecosystems and resources.

This is going to have a profound effect on what our rights are and how they can be used in the future for other tribes,” he said. How do we make them have to get our consent? We need to understand how to assert our rights, and we just haven’t played these cards the right way yet.”

Support this work

Reader donations, many as small as just $5, are what fund the work of writers like this—and keep our content free and accessible to everyone. If you support this work, will chip in to help fund it?

It only takes a minute to donate. Click here to make a tax-deductible donation.

Alex Brown covers environmental issues for Stateline. Prior to joining Pew, Brown wrote for The Chronicle in Lewis County, Washington state. He’s won awards for investigative reporting and feature writing from the Pacific Northwest Newspaper Association. In 2017, Brown thru-hiked the 2,650-mile Pacific Crest Trail, which traverses mountain ranges from the Mexican border to the Canadian border. He previously was a congressional correspondent for National Journal, where he covered energy and environment, technology and campaigns. Brown graduated from Union University and is a native of Michigan.

Subscribe and Save 66%

Less than $1.67 an issue