It’s hardly a secret that the New York City Police Department (NYPD) has undercover officers in all manner of places. The department’s spying on Muslim communities has drawn particular attention, but the NYPD also has a track record of infiltrating activist communities. Following a high-profile incident involving an altercation between a motorcycle rally and an SUV driver last month, we’ve now learned that that infiltration extended to Occupy Sandy, the disaster relief offshoot of Occupy Wall Street.
After the city (or certain parts of it, anyway) was shocked by the altercation that left one motorcyclist in the hospital and ended with the vehicle’s driver being beaten by several of the bikers, rhetoric about “criminal biker gangs” became heated. Republican mayoral candidate Joe Lhota told the New York Post that recently-passed city laws to curb stop-and-frisk “have had a chilling effect among the NYPD” and are leading to a rise in violent crime.
There’s just one little problem: At least one of the bikers who was part of the assault was a cop himself.
As the story becomes clearer, we’ve learned that Detective Wojciech Braszczok, 32, was off-duty when he participated in the ride, making his claims that he didn’t come to the aid of driver Alexian Lien because he was afraid to blow his cover a little harder to believe. The detective has apparently been arrested and charged with riot and criminal mischief after video surfaced of him punching and kicking Lien’s vehicle.
The revelation that Braszczok participated in the so-called riot has calmed some of the city’s law-and-order freakouts, but it’s also brought further revelations in its wake — including that one of his undercover assignments was infiltrating Occupy Wall Street.
It is a shock to absolutely no one, of course, that the NYPD had undercovers at Occupy. The NYPD has eyes everywhere, as Jim Dwyer at the New York Times points out:
The city now has a sturdy legion of undercover officers who have taken up residence in many surprising regions of civic life. Much of this began in early 2003, when a federal judge lifted many restraints on spying by the Police Department. The city had been failed by the federal intelligence services, and thousands died on Sept. 11. Police Commissioner Raymond W. Kelly and Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg created an independent intelligence capacity.
So before and during the Iraq War, the organization of antiwar rallies was regarded as a fit matter for police surveillance; so were the monthly Critical Mass bicycle rallies, as well as groups protesting at the Republican National Convention in 2004, and a range of Islamic facilities, from mosques to college student clubs.
It’s perhaps slightly more surprising — but only slightly — that the NYPD felt the need to keep an eye on the Sandy relief work being done by Occupiers. Even billionaire soon-to-be-ex-Mayor Michael Bloomberg praised Occupy Sandy’s work, albeit grudgingly and perhaps in an attempt to deflect anger at his own failures. The immediate aftermath of Sandy brought an apparent détente between police and the organizers who’d been arrested, pepper-sprayed and repeatedly ejected from the park they’d called home. Meeting the immediate needs of New Yorkers without power, food, or transportation seemed to supersede all else.
It may not surprise us that peace went only so far, and that officers were in fact still present, trying to infiltrate an open organization that accepted donations and help from anyone who walked in. But the degree to which we’re resigned to this constant surveillance should worry us. If the NYPD’s biggest priority after a massive storm that left thousands homeless, trapped or stranded was making sure the people bringing them fresh water and medications weren’t slipping a little radical propaganda in with the hot meals, that should raise questions about what the police force is good for in the first place.
Last fall, after Sandy, I went out to the Rockaways to see what the storm had done to that part of the city. I spoke with residents who told me that the police were little help as they attempted to clean out flooded homes, check on neighbors and care for one another. Kenyatta Hutchinson, who had been flooded out of his house along with his wife and child, told me that he was afraid to remove his flat-screen TV from his own apartment because he might be accused of looting his own belongings. “All I see is cops, and they’re still harassing us,” he told me, a sentiment that was echoed by many of his neighbors in Arverne, a mostly black neighborhood.
New York’s communities of color have long known that the police are unlikely to help them in a crisis. The people who panicked over the motorcyclists are perhaps learning that lesson for the first time right now, as news of Detective Braszczok’s actions spreads.
But we shouldn’t forget that the real story here is the depth and breadth of the surveillance state, the way police departments and federal agencies have access to our emails and cell phones and infiltrate our political events. As Dwyer wrote, “One of the large, undiscussed questions of such surveillance is how civic dialogue can be influenced or distorted by police agents — perhaps as provocateurs, or possibly with no motive beyond maintaining cover.”
When the issue at hand is not just civic dialogue, but life-saving disaster relief work, how much does the NYPD’s intrusion hurt?
Sarah Jaffe is a writer and reporter living in New Orleans and on the road. She is the author of Work Won’t Love You Back: How Devotion To Our Jobs Keeps Us Exploited, Exhausted, and Alone; Necessary Trouble: Americans in Revolt, and the forthcoming From the Ashes: Grief and Revolution in a World on Fire, all from Bold Type Books. Her journalism covers the politics of power, from the workplace to the streets, and her writing has been published in The Nation, The Washington Post, The Guardian, The New Republic, the New York Review of Books, and many other outlets. She is a columnist at The Progressive and a contributing writer at In These Times. She also co-hosts the Belabored podcast, with Michelle Chen, covering today’s labor movement, and Heart Reacts, with Craig Gent, an advice podcast for the collapse of late capitalism. Sarah has been a waitress, a bicycle mechanic, and a social media consultant, cleaned up trash and scooped ice cream and explained Soviet communism to middle schoolers. Journalism pays better than some of these. You can follow her on Twitter @sarahljaffe.
